Xbox One and Playstation 4 highest user-ranked games of all time

I made a top 100 list of PlayStation 4 and Xbox One games, by user rating. I could not find this anywhere so I made my own list. I think the user scores are more honest than critic scores because many critics only play the game for an hour before making a decision, while users play them all the way through (I used to be a critic so I know this!)

For example the #3 highest user rated game on PS4, Bloodborne, got a lousy 40th rank by critics! The #5 game, Pillars of Eternity, was ranked 70th by critics.

Top PS4 games by user rating	User rating	Release date	Critic rank (1=highest)
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt	User: 9.2	5/19/2015	10
The Last of Us Remastered	User: 9.1	7/29/2014	3
Bloodborne: The Old Hunters	User: 9.1	11/24/2015	43
Persona 5	User: 9.0	4/4/2017	5
Pillars of Eternity: Complete Edition	User: 8.9	8/29/2017	70
Bloodborne	User: 8.8	3/24/2015	9
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt - Blood and Wine	User: 8.8	5/30/2016	11
Dark Souls III	User: 8.8	4/12/2016	24
Sonic Mania	User: 8.8	8/15/2017	62

expand list. (top 100)

Top Xbox One games by user rating	User rating	Release date	Critic rank (1=highest)
Pillars of Eternity: Complete Edition	User: 9.6	8/29/2017	51
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt	User: 9.2	5/19/2015	6
Dark Souls III	User: 8.6	4/12/2016	25
Ori and the Blind Forest	User: 8.5	3/11/2015	21
BioShock: The Collection	User: 8.5	9/13/2016	63
Observer	User: 8.4	8/15/2017	36
Rocket League	User: 8.3	2/17/2016	27
Forza Horizon 2	User: 8.3	9/30/2014	47
Tales From The Borderlands: Episode 1 - Zer0 Sum	User: 8.3	11/26/2014	91

This is based on aggregated scores.

expand list. (top 100)